Has ‘Rachel from accounts’ messed up the UK economy?

UK budget

The pound has continued to fall after UK government borrowing costs rose and concerns grew about public finances

Sterling dropped as UK 10-year borrowing costs surged to their highest level since the 2008 financial crisis when bank borrowing virtually ground to a halt.

Economists have warned the rising costs could lead to further tax rises or cuts to spending plans as the government tries to meet its self-imposed borrowing target.

The UK government creates its own financial crisis as it messes up its ‘go for growth’ policy

The UK economy is currently grappling with a series of financial challenges that have led to a significant fall in the value of the pound, soaring treasury yields, and high borrowing costs.

These developments have been largely influenced by the recent budget announced by Chancellor Rachel Reeves, which has sparked concerns among investors and economists alike.

Downward trajectory

The pound has been on a downward trajectory, recently hitting its lowest level since November 2023. Traders are betting on further declines, with some predicting the pound could fall as low as $1.12

This decline is partly due to the rising cost of government borrowing, which has surged to levels not seen since the 2008 financial crisis. The yield on 10-year gilts has climbed to 4.8%, while the yield on 30-year gilts has reached 5.34%, the highest in 27 years.

Recent UK budget

The recent budget has played a crucial role in these developments. Announced in October 2024, the budget included significant tax hikes and increased spending, leading to a substantial rise in government borrowing.

The budget deficit is expected to reach 4.5% of GDP this fiscal year, pushing the overall government debt close to 100% of GDP. This increase in borrowing has led to a higher supply of government debt, which in turn has driven down the price of bonds and pushed up yields.

Higher yields

Higher yields mean that the government has to pay more to borrow money, which has significant implications for its fiscal policy. The rising cost of servicing government debt could force the government to either raise taxes further or cut spending to meet its fiscal rules.

This situation is reminiscent of the market turmoil following Liz Truss’s mini budget in 2022, which also led to a sharp rise in borrowing costs and a fall in the value of the pound.

The impact of these developments extends beyond the government. Higher borrowing costs are likely to affect households and businesses as well.

Economic growth at risk

Mortgage rates, which are influenced by government bond yields, are expected to remain high, putting additional pressure on homeowners. Businesses, on the other hand, may face higher costs of borrowing, which could lead to reduced investment and slower economic growth.

The UK is facing a challenging economic environment characterized by a falling pound, high treasury yields, and rising borrowing costs.

The recent budget has exacerbated these issues, leading to increased government borrowing and higher debt levels. As the government navigates these challenges, it will need to carefully balance its fiscal policies to avoid further economic instability and ensure sustainable growth and not more ‘unfunded’ debt.

Euro zone inflation rose to 2.4% in December 2024 – as expected

Inflation

The annual inflation rate in euro zone increased for the consecutive month reaching 2.4% in December 2024, according to the statistics released on Tuesday 7th January 2024 by Eurostat

The reading, according to economists’ forecasts, indicated an increase from a revised 2.2% figure in November 2024. Core inflation remained steady at 2.7% for the fourth consecutive month, meeting economists’ expectations, while services inflation edged up to 4% from 3.9%.

Headline inflation was widely expected to accelerate after hitting a low of 1.7% in September 2024, as the effect from lower energy prices fade.

The European Central Bank will monitor the full extent of increases in the reading, as well as persistence in services and core inflation. Markets currently anticipate that the ECB will reduce rates from 3% to 2% through several cuts this year.

UK economy had zero growth between July and September 2024 – bad to worse

UK economic data

Revised official figures indicate that the UK economy was weaker than initially estimated between July and September 2024. The economy experienced zero growth in these three months, down from an earlier estimate of 0.1%.

UK Chancellor, Rachel Reeves reportedly stated that the challenge to fix the economy “after 15 years of neglect is huge,” and October’s Budget would “deliver sustainable long-term growth, putting more money in people’s pockets.”

However, one of the UK’s leading business groups, the CBI, said its latest company survey suggested “the economy is headed for the worst of all worlds.”

The downward revisions will be a setback for Labour, which has prioritised boosting economic growth. It has promised to deliver the highest sustained economic growth in the G7 group of wealthy nations.

Separate figures released last week showed that inflation, the rate at which prices increase over time, is rising again at its fastest pace since March 2024. But it is close to the Bank of England target of 2%

The Bank of England voted to hold interest rates at the last meeting, stating that it believed the UK economy had performed worse than expected, with no growth between October and December 2024.

Businesses have warned that measures announced in October’s Budget, including a rise in employer national insurance and a higher minimum wage, could force them to raise prices and reduce the number new jobs.

U.S. inflation reading of 2.4% for November 2024 is better than expected

Inflation PCE

The PCE price index, the Fed’s preferred inflation gauge, showed an increase of just 0.1% from October and a 2.4% annual rate – which was below expectations.

Excluding food and energy, core PCE also increased 0.1% monthly and was 2.8% higher from a year ago, with both readings being 0.1% off the forecast.

The personal consumption expenditures price index (PCE) – the Fed’s preferred inflation gauge, showed an increase of just 0.1% from October 2024.

The reading indicated a 2.4% inflation rate on an annual basis, still ahead of the Fed’s 2% goal, but lower than the 2.5% consensus estimate.

The markets cheered the inflation report and recovered loses after yesterdays (19th December 2024) FOMC meeting where the Fed announced it may only reduce interest rates on two more occasions in 2025 – even after a 0.25% rate reduction.

Fed cuts interest rate by 0.25% – indicates fewer cuts in 2025

U.S. interest rate

The Federal Open Market Committee (FOMC) cut its borrowing rate to a range of 4.25% – 4.50%, mirroring its December 2022 level.

The Fed indicated that it probably would only lower twice more in 2025, according to the closely watched ‘dot plot’ matrix of individual members’ future rate expectations

While the decision itself was closely watched, the primary concern centered on what they would communicate regarding its future direction, considering inflation remains above and economic growth is relatively – conditions that do not typically align with easing.

The Fed said that it would probably only lower the interest rate twice in 2025. The markets reacted with a sharp pullback with the Dow hitting a 10-day losing streak – last seen in 1974.

Dow down again – falling for 10th consecutive day

Dow down

The Dow Industrial Average dropped 1,123 points to 42,326.87, marking its 10th consecutive day of decline and the longest since 1974.

The Dow is lining up for potentially its worst weekly performance since March 2023.

The S&P 500 fell 2.95% to 5,872.16, while the Nasdaq Composite decreased 3.56% 19,392.69 as losses in the tech-heavy index accelerated at the end of the session.

Both the 30-stock Dow and the S&P 500 recorded their largest one-day loss since August 2024.

The Dow and most other indices reacted badly to the Feds interest prediction for 2025 – suggesting ‘maybe’ only two more rates cuts to come.

Dow Jones one-day chart 18th December 2024 (after FOMC interest rate announcement)

Dow Jones one-day chart 18th December 2024 (after FOMC interest rate announcement)

UK inflation rate rises to 2.6% to hit highest level since March 2024

The UK inflation rate has gone up for the second month in a row, rising at the fastest pace since March 2024. The UK inflation rate rose to 2.6% in the year to November 2024, according to official figures.

However, the rise was predicted by economists and was apparently within the range of the expected increase anticipated.

Fuel and clothing were significant contributors to the increase. Additionally, rising ticket prices for concerts and theatrical performances played a role according to data from the Office for National Statistics (ONS).

The Bank of England raises interest rates to maintain inflation at its target of %. The next rate decision is on Thursday 19th December 2024 and economists anticipate that rates will remain at 4.75%.

Prices for food and non-alcoholic drinks, alcohol and tobacco, and footwear all rose at a faster pace last month.

A wider measure of inflation showed housing and household services costs, including rent, rose by 3.5%.

UK inflation 2016 – 2024

UK inflation 2016 – 2024

UK economy shrinks unexpectedly for second month in a row contracting 0.1% in October 2024

The U.K. economy contracted unexpectedly in October 2024, according to data from the Office for National Statistics (ONS).

Gross Domestic Product (GDP) fell by an estimated 0.1% on a monthly basis, the ONS said Friday 13th December 2024, attributing the downturn to a decline in production output. 

It marked the second consecutive economic downturn, following a 0.1% GDP decline in September 2024. Sterling declined on the back of these disappointing figures, trading 0.3% lower against the U.S. dollar in early trade.

However, ‘real’ GDP is estimated to have grown 0.1% in the three months to October 2024, the ONS said, compared to the previous three months ending in July 2024.

In a statement on Friday 13th December 2024, U.K. Finance Minister Rachel Reeves reportedly conceded that the October figures were ‘disappointing,’ but defended the government’s economic strategies. I expect the chancellor would have been quick to own the success had the GDP improved – especially after the ‘for growth’ budget.

The economy has grown just once over the past five months and is 0.1% lower than before Labour won the election. That may suggest it’s not just the Budget that is holding the economy back. Instead, the drag from higher interest rates may be lasting longer than was calculated.

Either way, be it budget or inflation pressure – the UK economy isn’t growing.

UK GDP January 2022 – October 2024

Note: preliminary ONS figures may be revised in future assessments

U.S. annual inflation rate increases to 2.7% in November 2024 – as expected

Inflation U.S.

U.S. consumer prices rose at a faster annual pace in November 2024, a reminder that inflation remains an issue both for households and policymakers.

The consumer price index (CPI) showed a 12-month inflation rate of 2.7% after increasing 0.3% on the month, the Bureau of Labor Statistics reported Wednesday 11th November 2024. The annual rate was 0.1 percentage point higher than October 2024.

Excluding food and energy costs, the core CPI was at 3.3% on an annual basis and 0.3% monthly. The 12-month core number was unchanged from a month ago.

All of the numbers were in line with consensus estimates.

The data comes with Federal Reserve deciding over what to do at their policy meeting next week. Markets strongly expect the Fed to lower its benchmark short-term borrowing rate by 0.25% at the meeting on 18th December 2024.

It is unlikely now that a January rate cut will happen as the FOMC measures the impact recent cuts have had on the economy.

Odds are of a 99% certainty of a cut in December 2024.

Tesla shares climb to record high – boosted by Trump election victory

Tesla EV

Tesla shares soared to an all-time high on Wednesday exceeding their previous record set in 2021, driven by a post-election rally and heightened enthusiasm Wall Street for Elon Musk’s electric vehicle company.

The stock increased to an intraday high of $415, exceeding its previous peak by 50 cents and closed above its highest finish of $409.97 recorded on 4th November 2021.

Tesla’s market has increased reportedly increased by around 69% this year, with nearly all of those gains occurring after Trump’s election victory early last month. The stock’s 38% rally in represented its monthly performance since January 2023 and ranks as the 10th best on record.

Reportedly according to Federal Election Commission filings, Musk invested $277 million into a pro-Trump campaign effort and transformed his support for the Republican nominee into a full-time job in the lead-up to the election. He financed an operation in swing states to register voters and utilised his social media platform, to promote his chosen candidate, often disseminating misinformation.

The world’s wealthiest individual, whose net worth has increased to over $360 billion, is poised to head the Trump administration’s ‘Department of Government Efficiency,’ DOGE – together with former Republican presidential candidate Vivek Ramaswamy.

The newly formed DOGE will be tasked with culling government bureaucracy by streamlining and junking departments.

Musk’s role may grant him authority over the budgets and staffing of federal agencies, well as the capability to advocate for the removal of inconvenient regulations. During a Tesla earnings call in October, Musk reportedly stated intention to leverage his influence with Trump to create ‘Federal approval for autonomous vehicles.’ At present, approvals are at the state level.

Is business now openly running he U.S. government?

UK business confidence falls to lowest level in almost two years after Labour budget

In November 2024, business confidence in the U.K. dropped to its lowest point since January 2023, as reported by BDO, a business advisory and accountancy firm.

Concurrently, KPMG noted that UK job vacancies decreased at the quickest pace since the pandemic began. This downturn coincides with warnings from businesses that the Labour Party’s ‘pro-growth’ budget could exacerbate inflation and decelerate hiring.

Tax increases do not fit well with a ‘pro-growth’ agenda. Also, GDP predictions made by the UK chancellor for 2025 through 2027 are lame.

The Labour budget has notably affected U.K. business confidence for a variety of critical reasons:

  • Tax Increases: The budget introduced a substantial hike in National Insurance contributions for employers, raising the rate to 15% on salaries above £5,000. This increase has led to concerns about higher operational costs, which many businesses fear will result in job cuts and reduced investment.
  • Minimum Wage Hike: The budget also included an inflation-busting increase in the minimum wage. While this aims to improve living standards, it has added financial pressure on businesses, particularly those in sectors with tight margins like retail and hospitality.
  • Economic Uncertainty: The combination of these measures has created a sense of economic uncertainty. Businesses are worried about their ability to absorb these additional costs, leading to a decline in overall optimism.
  • Investment Concerns: The increased costs have forced many businesses to reconsider their investment plans. Some have already announced cuts to expansion projects and other growth initiatives.
  • Next Increase: in public workers pay looms nigh.

These factors have collectively contributed to a significant drop in business confidence, with many firms bracing for a challenging economic environment ahead

U.S. Fed’s preferred inflation measure rises to 2.3% 

U.S. inflation

The Personal Consumption Expenditures (PCE) price index announced 27th November 2025, rose by 0.2% monthly, matching a 12-month inflation rate of 2.3%, aligning with expectations.

Core U.S. inflation recorded more robust figures, climbing 0.3% monthly and reaching an annual rate of 2.8%, but also in accordance with forecasts.

Consumer spending increased by 0.4% monthly, as expected, while personal income surged by 0.6%, exceeding the estimated 0.3%.

The Federal Reserve is now likely searching for economic clues on how to proceed at its next interest rate meeting.

Deflation worries linger as China’s industrial profits reportedly fall by 10% in October 2024

China economy

In October 2024, China’s industrial profits fell by 10% compared to the previous year, indicating that the stimulus measures have not yet countered the downturn in corporate earnings.

This decline represents the third consecutive month of falling profits, succeeding a 27% year-on-year drop in September 2024, which was the most significant decrease since March 2020.

Industrial profits serve as an important indicator of the financial health of China’s factories, mines, and utilities.

For the first ten months, profits at China’s industrial companies saw a 4.3% reduction from the previous year, as reported by the National Bureau of Statistics of China on Wednesday 27th November 2024. This is in contrast to a 3.5% decrease reported up to September 2024.

The statistics bureau reportedly noted that the less severe decline in October 2024 was due to the application of Beijing’s stimulus measures.

The second-largest economy in the world expanded at its most modest rate in the third quarter since early 2023, struggling with subdued domestic consumption and an extended slump in the housing market.

However, retail sales in October 2024 exceeded forecasts with a 4.8% increase compared to the same period last year, and there was an improvement in the unemployment rate.

Are U.S. Stocks Overvalued?

The U.S. stock market has been a topic of much debate among investors and analysts, especially regarding its valuation levels. As of the end of 2024, several indicators suggest that U.S. stocks might be overvalued.

Buffet indicator

One of the most watched metrics is the Buffett Indicator, named after the legendary investor Warren Buffett. This indicator compares the total market capitalisation of U.S. stocks to the country’s gross domestic product (GDP).

Historically, a ratio above 100% is considered overvalued. As of September 30, 2024, this ratio stands at approximately 208%, significantly above the historical average and suggesting that the market is strongly overvalued.

P/E and CAPE

Another important metric is the Price-to-Earnings (P/E) ratio, which measures the price of stocks relative to their earnings. The cyclically adjusted P/E ratio (CAPE), popularised by economist Robert Shiller, provides a long-term view by averaging earnings over ten years.

The CAPE ratio for the S&P 500 is currently around 35, well above the historical average of 16-17. This high level indicates that investors are willing to pay a premium for stocks, which could be a sign of overvaluation.

Several factors contribute to these elevated valuations. Low interest rates have played a significant role, making bonds less attractive and pushing investors toward stocks. Additionally, the rapid technological advancements and growth in sectors like technology, AI, and healthcare have driven up stock prices. Companies in these sectors have experienced significant revenue growth, leading to higher valuations.

High valuations

However, these high valuations come with risks. The market’s current levels are pricing in a lot of optimism about future growth and profitability. Any economic slowdown, policy changes, or unforeseen global events could trigger a market correction. Investors must remain cautious and consider the potential for volatility.

On the other hand, some analysts argue that the current valuation levels can be justified by the robust corporate earnings and strong economic fundamentals. They point out that the U.S. economy has shown resilience in the face of challenges, and many companies have adapted well to the changing environment.

Summary

In conclusion, while U.S. stocks are currently expensive and may be overvalued by historical standards, it’s essential to understand the underlying factors and potential risks.

Investors should stay informed, diversify their portfolios, and be prepared for possible market fluctuations. As always, a balanced approach to investing, considering both the potential rewards and risks, is crucial.

Always do your own and careful – RESEARCH! RESEARCH! RESEARCH!

An seek professional financial advice.

UK inflation unexpectedly rises to 2.3% in October 2024

UK shoppers

The inflation rate, which measures price changes, hit 2.3% in the year to October 2024, a bigger-than-expected increase from 1.7% in September 2024.

The increase was in part due to an increase in the regulator-set energy price cap that took effect in October 2024, which is expected to increase energy price inflation through the winter.

The Office for National Statistics (ONS), said while higher energy costs had contributed, this increase was offset by falls in live music and theatre ticket prices.

October 2024 UK inflation

October 2024 UK inflation

Mega port opens in Latin America to Chinese fanfare

Container port

The inauguration of Chancay Port in Peru represents a significant development in China-Peru relations and is set to revolutionise trade facilities within Latin America.

This $3.5 billion mega port, opened by Chinese President Xi Jinping and Peruvian President Dina Boluarte, is a component of China’s Belt and Road Initiative (BRI) and seeks to improve connectivity between South America and Asia.

Located about 80 kilometres north of Lima, the deep-water port is anticipated to emerge as a significant trade hub, especially for commerce with China. Boasting a draft depth of 17.8 metres, the Chancay port is capable of hosting the largest container ships in the world, which is expected to considerably cut down shipping durations and logistical expenses.

The port has the potential to process over 1 million TEUs (twenty-foot equivalent units) each year, enhancing Peru’s position as a key logistical centre in the region.

Job creation

The Chancay Port is expected to generate over 8,000 jobs in the coming decade, aiding in the export of minerals such as lithium and copper from Chile and Peru. It will also facilitate the import of Asian electronics, textiles, and other consumer goods, further connecting Latin American markets with Asia.

Peruvian authorities see the port as a move towards transforming Peru into the ‘Singapore of Latin America’, boosting its role as a global trade centre.

The Chancay Port aims to rival other significant ports in the area, like Mexico’s Port of Manzanillo and California’s Long Beach, by offering direct routes to Asia and cutting shipping times by as much as 20 days.

Expansion

This progress highlights China’s expanding role in Latin America and its dedication to strengthening economic relationships within the region. The Chancay Port represents not only a conduit for commerce but also a sign of the increasingly close partnership between China and Latin America.

President Xi Jinping himself attended the inauguration of the Chancay port, an indication of just how seriously China takes the development.

There is a strong perception that the U.S. is losing ground in Latin America as China forges ahead with its Belt and Road Initiative (BRI).

The deep-water port also potentially carries military implications for the U.S. too.

UK growth slows – it’s the ‘budget’ stupid!

Low UK growth figures

The UK economy expanded by just 0.1% from July to September 2024, as announced in the most recent official data release.

The growth was less than anticipated, and the Office for National Statistics (ONS) reported that most sectors experienced subdued activity over the quarter.

Labour, having prioritised economic growth upon assuming power, found Chancellor Rachel Reeves expressing dissatisfaction with these figures, which represent the initial three months of the new administration.

Several economists have attributed the uncertainty surrounding the contents of October’s Budget as a factor impeding growth.

This impact was notably pronounced in September, when the economy saw a contraction of 0.1%.

Moreover, the government is contending with criticism from certain businesses that are opposed to the tax increases introduced in the Budget.

Whichever way you look at these figures; they’re utterly dire.

U.S. inflation rate at 2.6% in October 2024 as expected

U.S. inflation

In October 2024, the U.S. consumer price index rose by 0.2%, bringing the annual inflation rate to 2.6%, aligning with expectations, according to the U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics.

The core CPI, which excludes food and energy, saw a monthly increase of 0.3% and an annual rate of 3.3%, also in line with projections.

For the month, the consumer price index, assessing a range of goods and services, went up by 0.2%. This increment raised the year-over-year inflation rate to 2.6%, a 0.2% increase from September 2024.

These figures matched estimates. When food and energy were excluded, the core CPI’s monthly rise was even more significant, at 0.3%, with an annual rate of 3.3%, confirming the forecasts.

Trump announces the new ‘Department of Government Efficiency’- DOGE – Dogecoin climbs over 150% on the news

DOGE

The purchase of Meme coins is often viewed as indicators of retail interest and the willingness to take risks in the cryptocurrency market. Increased activity in meme coins typically signals that retail investors are engaging and are inclined to speculate more aggressively on the risk spectrum.

Trump initially proposed the concept of an efficiency commission in September 2024. Since that time, Musk -who has previously referred to himself as the ‘Dogefather’ – is known for making public statements about the meme coin that affect its value, has posted on his social media platform X, referring to the commission as theDepartment of Government Efficiency’ or ‘D.O.G.E.

Dogecoin’s relevance surged in 2021 due to Elon Musk’s endorsement and the continuous hype on social media, which became a significant catalyst for the cryptocurrency. In May of that year, Musk’s tweets propelled Dogecoin to its peak value around 67 cents, according to market analysis. However, his reference to Dogecoin as ‘a hustle’, caused its value to plummet.

Recently, Dogecoin’s value increased following the post-election announcement by President-elect Donald Trump about the establishment of theDepartment of Government Efficiency‘, which he acronymized as ‘DOGE’ in his statement.

Elon Musk, CEO of Tesla, and Vivek Ramaswamy, the former Republican presidential candidate and co-founder of Strive Asset Management, have been appointed to lead this department.

According to Trump’s statement, their role will be instrumental in his administration’s efforts to dismantle government bureaucracy, reduce unnecessary regulations, eliminate wasteful spending, and reorganise federal agencies.

It’s time for D.O.G.E.

U.S. stocks just keep hitting new highs!

U.S. stocks up!

The U.S. stock market sunbathed in another day of records on Friday 8th November 2024.

The Dow and S&P 500 recorded their best week in a year after Trump’s election win.

The Dow Jones Industrial Average rose 259.65 points to close at 43,988.99 and broke the 44,000 barrier in intraday trading. The Dow Jones traded above 44,000 for the first time ever during the session.

The S&P 500 closed at 5,995.54, after briefly trading above 6,000 – a first for the S&P 500.

The tech-heavy Nasdaq Composite slowed at 19,286.78 but set an intraday record high as well.

Dow Jones one-year chart as of: 8th November 2024

Dow Jones one-year chart as of: 8th November 2024

S&P 500 one-year chart as of: 8th November 2024

S&P 500 one-year chart as of: 8th November 2024

Bank of England lowers UK interest rate by 0.25% to 4.75%

Interest rate down

The Bank of England cut interest rates by 0.25% Thursday 7th November 2024, even as Labour’s budget announcement confuses the outlook for future policy easing.

The anticipated reduction, marking the central bank’s second this year, lowers the key rate to 4.75%.

Financial markets had forecast a high probability of the quarter-point decrease at the November 2024 meeting, although analysts cautioned that future cuts might be postponed due to the Labour government’s tax-and-spend budget.

Investors are now awaiting remarks from Governor Andrew Bailey and his team regarding their updated economic forecast following the budget and the U.S. presidential election.

Exports for China in October 2024 up sharply beating expectations

Exports

China exports reportedly rose by 12.7% year on year to $309.06 billion in October 2024 – the highest jump since March 2023 when they rose 14.8% according to recent data reports.

Imports, however, declined by a more-than-expected 2.3% in October, according to customs data.

The world’s second-largest economy is facing challenges with weakening domestic consumption and an ongoing property crisis, with exports emerging as a bright spot.

Dow hits new all-time high as Trump wins 2024 U.S. election

U.S. stocks at all time high

The Dow, S&P 500 and Nasdaq all hit new highs!

Stocks rallied sharply on Wednesday 6th November 2024, with major indices hitting record highs, as Donald Trump won the 2024 presidential election.

It looks like the Trump rally has already begun.

The Dow Jones Industrial Average surged 1,508.05 points to a record close of 43,729.93. The last time the Dow jumped more than 1,000 points in a single day was in November 2022.

The S&P 500 also hit an all-time high, soaring to 5,929.04. The Nasdaq Composite climbed to a record of its own too of 18,983.47.

Dow Jones one-year chart as of 6th November 2024

Dow Jones one-year chart as of 6th November 2024

S&P 500 one-year chart as of 6th November 2024

S&P 500 one-year chart as of 6th November 2024

Nasdaq Composite one-year chart as of 6th November 2024

Nasdaq Composite one-year chart as of 6th November 2024