‘A pig in lipstick’ – Trump’s strategic Bitcoin reserve criticised

Pig in lipstick

The announcement of Donald Trump’s Strategic Bitcoin Reserve has sparked a wave of criticism and debate, with detractors likening the initiative to ‘a pig in lipstick’ – a superficial attempt to dress up a flawed concept.

The reserve, which aims to stockpile or create a strategic reserve Bitcoin seized through criminal and civil forfeitures, has been touted as a bold move to position the United States as a leader in the cryptocurrency space. However, critics argue that the plan is fraught with risks and questionable motives.

One of the primary concerns is Bitcoin’s notorious volatility. Unlike traditional reserve assets such as gold or oil, Bitcoin’s value can fluctuate wildly, making it a precarious choice for a national reserve.

Economists warn that integrating such an unpredictable asset into government holdings could destabilise financial strategies rather than strengthen them.

Moreover, the initiative has raised eyebrows over its potential conflicts of interest. Critics point out that Trump’s administration has shown a growing affinity for cryptocurrency, with some officials previously holding stakes in digital assets.

This has led to accusations that the reserve could serve as a vehicle for personal or political gain rather than a genuine effort to bolster national economic security.

Supporters of the reserve argue that it represents a forward-thinking approach to embracing digital assets as ‘digital gold.’ They believe that retaining seized Bitcoin, rather than auctioning it off, could provide long-term financial benefits and signal the U.S.’s commitment to innovation in the crypto space.

However, even some crypto enthusiasts are skeptical, questioning whether the reserve’s creation is more about optics than substance.

In the end, the Strategic Bitcoin Reserve has ignited a broader conversation about the role of cryptocurrency in national policy. Whether it proves to be a visionary move, or a misguided gamble remains to be seen.

For now, the debate goes on.

Trump’s U.S. Bitcoin reserve plan falls short of expectations

National U.S. crypto reserve

The cryptocurrency market faced a significant downturn following the announcement of President Donald Trump’s U.S. Bitcoin reserve plan

The initiative aimed to position the United States as a global digital asset leader fell short of market expectations, triggering a wave of selloffs.

Bitcoin, the flagship cryptocurrency, experienced a 3% drop, trading at $87,586.86 before dipping further to $84,688.13. Other major cryptocurrencies, including Ethereum, XRP, and Solana, also saw declines, with Cardano’s ADA token suffering a sharp 13% drop.

The market’s reaction underscores the gap between investor hopes and the plan’s immediate implications.

The executive order established a strategic bitcoin reserve funded exclusively by assets seized in criminal and civil proceedings. While this approach ensures no taxpayer burden, it disappointed investors who anticipated direct government purchases to bolster Bitcoin’s value.

White House Crypto and AI Czar David Sacks emphasised the reserve’s role as a ‘digital Fort Knox’, but the lack of immediate buy pressure dampened market sentiment.

The broader economic context also played a role. Weakness in equities and ongoing tariff concerns added to the uncertainty, compounding the market’s reaction.

Analysts noted that while the reserve plan is a step toward legitimising cryptocurrencies, its short-term impact on prices was underwhelming.

Despite the initial disappointment, the strategic reserve could have long-term benefits. By centralising and securing digital assets, the U.S. government aims to strengthen its position in the global financial system.

However, for now, the market remains volatile, reflecting the challenges of balancing innovation with investor expectations.

As the crypto landscape evolves, the success of such initiatives will depend on their ability to deliver tangible value to both the market and the broader economy.

Will the U.S. government create a strategic crypto reserve by directly buying the digital asset and holding it as a national reserve?

At this moment in time, only Trump has that ‘key’.

Trump’s SEC prepares new ‘crypto task force’ to regulate the industry

Crypto regulation

On 21st January 2025, the U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC) announced the formation of a new cryptocurrency task force under the leadership of President Donald Trump.

This initiative marks a significant shift in the regulatory landscape for digital assets, aiming to provide a comprehensive and clear framework for the industry.

Task force

The task force, led by Commissioner Hester Peirce, also known as ‘Crypto Mom,’ is designed to address the regulatory challenges that have plagued the crypto industry for years.

The primary objectives of the task force include drawing clear regulatory lines, providing realistic paths to registration, crafting sensible disclosure frameworks, and deploying enforcement resources judiciously.

This approach contrasts sharply with the previous administration’s reliance on enforcement actions, which often left the industry in a state of confusion and uncertainty.

The announcement has generated a wave of optimism among crypto enthusiasts and investors. The price of Bitcoin, for instance, saw a notable increase following the news, reflecting the market’s positive reception.

But before this announcement, Bitcoin was already in an upward trajectory following the positive news swirling around Trump after he won the U.S. election.

Industry leaders are hopeful that the new regulatory environment will foster innovation while protecting investors and maintaining market integrity.

Commodity Futures Trading Commission

One of the key aspects of the task force’s mandate is to collaborate with other government agencies, Congress, and international bodies to ensure a cohesive regulatory approach.

This includes working closely with the Commodity Futures Trading Commission (CFTC) and other federal departments to harmonize regulations and provide technical assistance to Congress as it considers changes to the existing legal framework.

The task force’s formation is seen as a pivotal moment for the crypto industry, signalling a more welcoming and structured regulatory environment. As the task force begins its work, the industry eagerly anticipates the development of clear and practical guidelines that will support the growth and maturation of the digital asset market.

UK plans to regulate crypto industry

Crypto

The UK government said it intends to bring a number of crypto asset activities under the same regulations that govern banks and other financial services firms.

The U.K. government has recently announced its plans to regulate the crypto industry with formal legislation by 2024. The government aims to protect consumers and grow the economy by ensuring robust, transparent, and fair standards for crypto activities. Some of the proposed measures include:

Regulating a broad suite of crypto activities, such as trading, lending, and custody services.

Strengthening rules for crypto trading platforms and requiring them to have admission and disclosure documents.

Introducing a crypto market abuse regime to prevent manipulation and fraud.

Enhancing oversight of stablecoins, which are digital tokens pegged to fiat currencies or other assets.

The government’s consultation paper is open for feedback until January 31, 2024. 

The government said it is committed to embracing technological change and innovation, while mitigating the most significant risks posed by crypto-assets.