The Nixon shock: When politics undermined the Fed—and markets paid the price

Nixon Fed Interference shock

In the early 1970s, President Richard Nixon’s pursuit of re-election collided with the Federal Reserve’s independence, triggering a cascade of economic consequences that reshaped global finance.

The episode remains a cautionary tale about the dangers of politicising monetary policy.

At the heart of the drama was Nixon’s pressure on Fed Chair at the time, Arthur Burns to stimulate the economy ahead of the 1972 election. Oval Office tapes later revealed Nixon’s direct appeals for rate cuts and looser credit conditions—despite rising inflation.

Burns, reluctant but ultimately compliant, oversaw a period of aggressive monetary expansion. Interest rates were held artificially low, and the money supply surged.

Dow historical chart – lowest 43 points to around 45,400

The short-term result was a booming economy and a landslide victory for Nixon. But the longer-term consequences were severe. Inflation, already simmering, began to boil. By 1973, consumer prices were rising at an annual rate of over 6%, and the dollar was under siege in global markets.

Then came the real shock: in August 1971, Nixon unilaterally suspended the dollar’s convertibility into gold, effectively ending the Bretton Woods system.

This move—intended to halt speculative attacks and preserve U.S. gold reserves—unleashed a new era of floating exchange rates and fiat currency. The dollar depreciated sharply, and global markets entered a period of volatility.

By 1974, the consequences were fully visible. The Dow Jones Industrial Average had fallen nearly 45% from its 1973 peak.

Politics vs the Federal Reserve – lesson learned?

Bond yields soared as investors demanded compensation for inflation risk. The U.S. economy entered a deep recession, compounded by the oil embargo and geopolitical tensions.

The Nixon-Burns episode is now widely viewed as a breach of central bank independence. It demonstrated how short-term political gains can lead to long-term economic instability.

The Fed’s credibility was damaged, and it took nearly a decade—culminating in Paul Volcker’s brutal rate hikes of the early 1980s—to restore price stability.

Today, as debates over Fed autonomy resurface, the lessons of the 1970s remain urgent. Markets thrive on trust, transparency, and institutional integrity. When those are compromised, even the most powerful economies can falter.

THE NIXON SHOCK — Early 1970’s Timeline

🔶 August 1971 Event: Gold convertibility suspended Market Impact: Dollar begins to weaken Context: Nixon ends Bretton Woods, launching the fiat currency era

🔴 November 1972 Event: Nixon re-elected Market Impact: Stocks rally briefly (+6%) Context: Fed policy remains loose under political pressure

🔵 January 1973 Event: Dow peaks Market Impact: Start of sharp decline Context: Inflation accelerates, investor confidence erodes

🟢 1974 Event: Watergate fallout, Nixon resigns Market Impact: Dow down 44% from 1973 high Context: Recession deepens, Fed credibility damaged.

Current dollar dive, stocks boom and bust (the Dow fell 19% in a year and then by 44% in 1975 from its January 1973 peak). U.S. 10-year Treasury yields surged (peaking at nearly 7.60% -close to twice today’s yield).

In hindsight, Nixon won the election—but lost the economy. And the Fed, caught in the crossfire, paid the price in credibility. It’s a reminder that monetary policy is no place for political theatre.

Is history repeating itself? Is Trump’s involvement different, or another catastrophe waiting to happen?

First interest rate cut for India since 2020

India interest rate

The Reserve Bank of India (RBI) has cut its benchmark interest rate by 25 basis points to 6.25%, marking the first rate cut since May 2020

This decision comes amid concerns over a slowdown in the world’s fifth-largest economy.

The central bank forecast real GDP growth for next fiscal year at 6.7%, and inflation rate at 4.2%.

The RBI’s Monetary Policy Committee (MPC) cited the need to support economic activity as the primary reason for the rate cut. The Indian economy has been experiencing sluggish growth, with GDP expanding at a slower pace than expected.

Data driven

The latest data shows that the economy grew by just 5.4% in the September quarter, the slowest rate in seven quarters. This slowdown has been attributed to tepid urban consumption and sluggish manufacturing.

Inflation, which had been a major concern for the RBI, has shown signs of easing. Retail inflation dropped to a four-month low of 5.22% in December 2024, providing the central bank with some room to focus on growth rather than solely on price stability.

RBI Governor Sanjay Malhotra, in his first monetary policy review, reportedly stated that inflation is expected to further moderate in 2025-26.

Benefits

The rate cut is expected to benefit borrowers, including homeowners and small businesses, by making borrowing cheaper. However, it may also lead to lower returns on fixed deposits, posing a challenge for savers, especially senior citizens who rely on interest income.

The government’s recent budget, which included sweeping income tax cuts, is also aimed at putting more money in the hands of consumers and boosting spending.

Together with the rate cut, these measures are expected to provide a much-needed stimulus to the economy.

While the rate cut is a positive step towards reviving growth, it also underscores the challenges facing the Indian economy.

The RBI will need to carefully monitor inflation and other economic indicators to ensure that the measures taken do not lead to unintended consequences such as higher inflation.

U.S. inflation reading of 2.4% for November 2024 is better than expected

Inflation PCE

The PCE price index, the Fed’s preferred inflation gauge, showed an increase of just 0.1% from October and a 2.4% annual rate – which was below expectations.

Excluding food and energy, core PCE also increased 0.1% monthly and was 2.8% higher from a year ago, with both readings being 0.1% off the forecast.

The personal consumption expenditures price index (PCE) – the Fed’s preferred inflation gauge, showed an increase of just 0.1% from October 2024.

The reading indicated a 2.4% inflation rate on an annual basis, still ahead of the Fed’s 2% goal, but lower than the 2.5% consensus estimate.

The markets cheered the inflation report and recovered loses after yesterdays (19th December 2024) FOMC meeting where the Fed announced it may only reduce interest rates on two more occasions in 2025 – even after a 0.25% rate reduction.

Is Switzerland about to experience deflation?

Deflated tyre

Switzerland may be at risk of entering deflationary territory in 2025 due to the strengthening of the Swiss franc, which is challenging policymakers’ control over price growth.

The Swiss National Bank has lowered interest rates three times this year as of September, attributing the country’s declining inflation rate to the robustness of the safe-haven currency, as well as to falling oil and electricity prices.

Analysts increasingly believe that the Swiss National Bank may need to engage in foreign currency intervention to avert a deflationary scenario.

Furthermore, the central bank has adjusted its forecasts downward, setting the average annual inflation rate for 2024 at 1.2%, down from 1.3%, and anticipating a price growth of 0.6% in 2025, a decrease from the previously forecasted 1.1%.

China cuts lending rates by 0.25%

China cuts interest rates

China on Monday 21st October 2024 lowered its main benchmark lending rates by 0.25%

The People’s Bank of China (PBOC) has announced a reduction in the one-year loan prime rate (LPR) to 3.1% and the five-year LPR to 3.6%.

The one-year LPR affects corporate and most household loans in China, whereas the five-year LPR is a reference for mortgage rates.

This adjustment was anticipated. The governor of China’s central bank reportedly on Friday 18th October 2024 hinted at a forum in Beijing that the loan prime benchmark rates would decrease by 0.20% to 0.25%.

ECB cuts rates for the third time this year by 0.25% to 3.25%

ECB interest rate cut

On Thursday 17th October 2024, the ECB announced its third interest rate reduction of 2024, as inflation risks within the European Union diminished more rapidly than anticipated.

At its October meeting, the central bank decreased the deposit rate by 0.25%. This decision followed a slowdown in the euro area’s price increases to 1.8% in September 2024, falling below the central bank’s target of 2%.

The EU interest rate is now: 3.25%

New Zealand central bank cuts rates by 0.50%

New Zealand Central Bank

New Zealand’s central bank has reduced its benchmark interest rate by 0.50% points following its monetary policy meeting, resulting in a consecutive interest rate reduction

This decrease sets the Reserve Bank of New Zealand’s interest rate at 4.75%, down from 5.25%. Economists surveyed by Reuters had anticipated this move.

Previously in August, the RBNZ made an ‘unexpected’ interest rate cut of 25 basis points. The central bank indicated that the extent of future reductions would hinge on its confidence in maintaining a low inflation environment.

In a statement, the central bank stated that it ‘assesses that annual consumer price inflation is within its 1% to 3% inflation target range and converging on the 2 percent midpoint.

New Zealand’s annual inflation rate reached 7.3% in the June quarter 2022, its highest level in over some 30 years. NZ inflation has since dropped to 3.3% as of June 2024, but still remains above the central banks medium term target range of between 1% and 3%.

Analysts are expecting a further cut in November 2024.

U.S. cuts interest rate aggressively by 0.50% bringing the Fed rate range to 4.75% – 5.0%

U.S. interest rate

The Federal Open Market Committee (FOMC) has voted to reduce the interest rate by 0.50% after having maintained its benchmark rate within the range of 5.25% to 5.50% since July 2023

The previous rate was the highest seen for 23 years and remained unchanged even though the Fed’s favoured inflation gauge has decreased from 3.3% to 2.5%, and the unemployment rate has climbed from 3.5% to 4.2% during this period.

Following the interest rate cut today, 18th September 2024 of 0.50%, the new rate now stands at 4.75% to 5.0%.

All roads lead to Fed rate cut as minutes point to ‘likely’ September 2024 reduction

Fed prediction

No surprise here then as the Fed have been signalling a cut for some time now

The Fed summary stated: “The vast majority” of participants at the July 30-31 meeting “observed that, if the data continued to come in about as expected, it would likely be appropriate to ease policy at the next meeting.”

Markets have fully factored in a rate cut for September, marking the first such move since the initial emergency reductions during the early stages of the Covid crisis.

See more about Fed rate cut signals here

Markets got to hear exactly what they wanted to hear from Fed chair Jerome Powell

FOMC

FOMC hold rates steady at 5.25% – 5.50%

Federal Reserve Chair Jerome Powell ended a press conference in which he gave markets exactly what they wanted; a strong indication of a September 2024 rate cut.

Powell says September 2024 rate cut ‘on the table’ if inflation continues to cool.

Federal Reserve officials held short-term interest rates steady but observed that inflation is getting closer to its 2% target.

The FOMC did not signal an immediate rate cut; they reiterated that further progress is necessary before considering rate reductions. However, Federal Reserve Chair Powell’s subsequent statement was markedly dovish, hinting at a potential rate cut in September 2024.

Markets were generally happy with the news after moving up all day in anticipation of the confirmation of a September cut. The Dow Jones, Nasdaq, Russell 2000 and S&P 500 all climbed before and after the news.

What the Fed said

Federal Reserve

Jerome Powell appears to be further paving the way for a rate cut at the next meeting in July 2024.

Federal Reserve Chair Jerome Powell reportedly said Monday 15th July 2024 that the central bank will not wait until inflation hits 2% to cut interest rates.

Powell referenced the idea that central bank policy works with ‘long and variable lags’ to explain why the Fed wouldn’t wait for its target to be hit.

‘The implication of that is that if you wait until inflation gets all the way down to 2%, you’ve probably waited too long, because the tightening that you’re doing, or the level of tightness that you have, is still having effects which will probably drive inflation below 2%,’ Powell reportedly said.

Instead, the Fed is looking for ‘greater confidence’ that inflation will return to the 2% level, Powell remarked.

‘What increases that confidence in that is more good inflation data, and lately here we have been getting some of that,’ he reportedly said.

Powell also said he thinks a ‘hard landing’ for the U.S. economy was not ‘a likely scenario.’

It looks like it is time for that rate cut, he didn’t say that!

Euro zone inflation unexpectedly falls to 2.4% in March 2024

EU inflation

Eurozone inflation eased to 2.4% in March 2024, as indicated by preliminary figures released on Wednesday 3rd April 2024.

This decrease has increased expectations that interest rate cuts may start in the summer 2024.

Market analysts anticipate that the central bank will commence reductions in interest rates starting in June 2024, reflecting recent communications from the ECB.

Fed minutes show no indication of U.S. rate cuts at last meeting

U.S. interest rate

Federal Reserve members, in their most recent meeting, gave little indication of cutting interest rates anytime soon, particularly as inflation remains well above their goal of 2%, according to minutes released Tuesday 21st November 2023. 

The detail of the meeting held 31st October – 1st November 2023, showed that Federal Open Market Committee (FOMC) members are still concerned that inflation could be stubborn or move higher, and that more may need to be done.

They indicated that policy would need to stay ‘restrictive’ at the very least, inflation is on a convincing move back to the central bank’s 2% goal.

Fed next meet 13th December 2023.

Russia surprises with massive interest rate hike hit of 3.5%

Russia Interest rate increase

Interest rate pushed to 12%

Russia’s central bank has announced a surprise hike in its key lending rate by 3.5%, from 8.5% to 12%, as the country’s economic recovery loses steam amid a resurgence of COVID-19 cases and weak domestic demand.

The decision was announced after an emergency meeting of the bank’s board of directors was called a day earlier as the ruble declined. The fall comes as Moscow increases military spending and Western sanctions weigh on its energy exports.

The Russian currency passed 101 roubles to the dollar on Monday, losing more than a third of its value since the beginning of the year and hitting the lowest level in almost 17 months. It had recovered slightly after the central bank announced the meeting.

The central bank blamed the weak ruble on ‘loose monetary policy‘, suggesting that bank has ‘all the tools necessary‘ to stabilize the situation.

More imports, less exports

By raising borrowing costs, the central bank is trying to fight price spikes as Russia imports more and exports less, especially oil and natural gas, with defense spending going up and sanctions taking a toll. Importing more and exporting less means a smaller trade surplus, which typically weighs on a country’s currency.

The bank also made a big rate hike of 1% last month, saying inflation is expected to keep rising and the fall in the ruble is adding to the risk.

After Western countries imposed sanctions on Russia over the invasion of Ukraine in February 2022, the ruble plunged to a low of 130 to the dollar, but the central bank enacted capital controls that stabilized its value.